Insights ~7 minute read

Non-Recourse Stock Loans: Non-, Limited- and Full-Recourse Compared.

A non-recourse stock loan limits the borrower’s liability to the pledged shares: if they are sold for less than the loan, the lender bears the loss. Full-recourse leaves the borrower liable for any shortfall; limited-recourse caps that liability at a defined level. Non-recourse typically runs at a lower loan-to-value than full-recourse on the same shares.

Stone columns of a Romanesque cloister in raking light

Stock-loan documentation distinguishes between three recourse profiles, and each is right for some positions and wrong for others. The differences are not pricing differences; they are differences in the structural allocation of risk between borrower and lender. Choosing the right profile for a specific position is one of the principal decisions at the structuring stage.

What is a full-recourse stock loan?

In a full-recourse structure, the borrower is liable for the full amount of the loan, irrespective of the value of the pledged shares. If the lender realises the pledged collateral for less than the outstanding loan, the borrower owes the difference as a deficiency claim.

Full-recourse is the simplest profile and the structure most common in standard banking practice. It preserves the highest LTV but exposes the borrower to a tail risk on the underlying.

Full-recourse is appropriate where the borrower has the financial standing to absorb a deficiency claim and is principally seeking maximum LTV. For a borrower with substantial unencumbered net worth beyond the pledged position, a deficiency claim is manageable, and the LTV advantage of full-recourse may be worth accepting the tail risk.

It is inappropriate where the pledged position represents a substantial portion of the borrower’s total net worth. In that case, a fall in the underlying that triggers liquidation and a deficiency claim could exceed the borrower’s resources, converting a stock-loan transaction into a personal-bankruptcy event. The instrument exists, in part, to avoid that outcome.

What is a non-recourse stock loan?

In a non-recourse structure, the borrower has no liability beyond the pledged collateral. If the underlying falls and the lender realises the collateral for less than the outstanding loan, the loss is the lender’s.

There is no deficiency claim against the borrower, which makes non-recourse the borrower-protective profile. The borrower’s worst-case outcome is the loss of the pledged shares.

Recourse is a separate question from who owns the shares during the loan. That turns on whether the structure is a pledge, a share charge or a title transfer: see who owns the shares during a stock loan.

Non-recourse is the structure most appropriate where the pledged position represents a substantial portion of the borrower’s net worth, and where the borrower’s principal objective is to bound the downside.

The trade-off is LTV: non-recourse structures typically run at lower LTV than full-recourse on the same underlying, because the lender is absorbing the tail risk. The LTV haircut is the price of the borrower protection.

Non-recourse is also the structure most appropriate where the borrower’s analytical view is that the underlying could materially decline. A founder who genuinely believes the share price could fall 50% may rationally accept a lower non-recourse LTV in exchange for the protection. The structure converts a personal-balance-sheet exposure into a defined-downside instrument.

What is a limited-recourse stock loan?

Limited-recourse structures sit between the two. The borrower is liable for the loan up to a defined threshold (commonly a percentage of the loan principal, or a stated cap), but not beyond.

If the underlying falls and the lender realises the collateral, the borrower covers the first portion of any deficiency up to the cap. The lender absorbs the remainder.

Limited-recourse is a calibrated middle ground. It allows the borrower to access a higher LTV than non-recourse, because the lender’s tail risk is bounded, while preserving a defined cap on the borrower’s downside.

The structuring discussion is the specific cap: what level of additional liability the borrower is willing to accept, and what LTV the lender will offer at that cap.

How do margin calls and other triggers work in each profile?

Each of the three profiles is further specified by its trigger structure: the events that cause the lender to act, and the consequences of those events. The principal triggers:

  • i
    Margin trigger. A fall in the underlying below a defined threshold (commonly expressed as a percentage of inception value, or as an LTV breach) triggers a margin call. The borrower has a defined period to meet the call with cash, additional collateral, or partial repayment, failing which the lender may realise the pledged collateral.
  • ii
    Stop-loss trigger. A fall below a deeper threshold triggers automatic liquidation without a margin call. This trigger is more common in non-recourse and limited-recourse structures, where the lender’s protection depends on liquidating before the collateral falls below the loan amount.
  • iii
    Floor. In non-recourse structures with a defined floor, a fall to the floor triggers transfer of the pledged collateral to the lender, releasing the borrower from further liability. The floor is the borrower’s defined downside.

The trigger structure is as important as the recourse profile. A non-recourse structure with an aggressive stop-loss trigger may, in practice, liquidate before the underlying has actually fallen far enough to materially threaten the lender.

That deprives the borrower of the protection the non-recourse profile was supposed to provide. Conversely, a full-recourse structure with no margin trigger may ride a falling underlying down to deficiency, converting a manageable margin event into an unmanageable balance-sheet event.

How do you choose between non-, limited- and full-recourse?

The choice between the three profiles is, in the firm’s framing, a function of three borrower-specific questions: How much of the borrower’s net worth does the pledged position represent? What is the borrower’s analytical view of the underlying’s downside? And what LTV does the borrower actually need from the transaction?

A high-net-worth borrower with a small pledge against a stable large-cap holding, seeking high LTV, may rationally choose full-recourse. A concentrated single-stock holder with most of their wealth in the pledged position, seeking modest liquidity, is typically better served by non-recourse. A controlling shareholder seeking material liquidity against a substantial holding may find limited-recourse the most appropriate middle ground.

The choice is structural, not stylistic. The firm does not recommend a profile in the abstract; the profile is calibrated to the position. What the firm offers is the framework for the choice and the indicative terms across multiple profiles, so that the borrower can compare the trade-offs explicitly before deciding.

At a glance
Recourse Profiles Compared

Full, limited, and non-recourse, side by side.

A comparison of full-recourse, limited-recourse, and non-recourse stock loans across the lender’s claim on default, the effect on loan-to-value, the effect on pricing, downside protection, and typical use.
Feature Full recourse Limited recourse Non-recourse
Lender’s claim on default The pledged shares plus a personal claim against the borrower for any shortfall. The pledged shares plus a claim capped at a defined amount or asset. The pledged shares only; the borrower can walk away and owes nothing further.
Effect on loan-to-value Supports the upper end of the range; the lender’s downside is best protected. Between the two; set by where the cap sits. Sits lower in the range; the lender prices in the tail risk it now carries.
Effect on pricing Tightest spread for a given position. Intermediate. Wider spread, reflecting the risk transfer to the lender.
Downside protection for the borrower None beyond the collateral; a fall below the loan can crystallise a personal liability. Bounded by the recourse cap. Strongest; a fall in the underlying below the loan is the lender’s risk, not the borrower’s.
Typically suits Holders prioritising maximum liquidity against a deep, liquid position. Holders seeking a defined, bounded exposure. Holders prioritising downside certainty over headline LTV.

A general comparison of recourse structures, indicative and illustrative only: not a quote or a representation about any specific transaction. See the disclosures.

Guide
Start Here

Where to start: the main guide.

How the loan itself works is set out in the main guide: securities-based lending: how securities-backed loans work. Market-by-market detail covers 38 exchanges in 34 countries.

FAQ
Common Questions

Non-recourse stock loans: frequently asked questions.

Q · 01

Is non-recourse always better for the borrower?

No: non-recourse caps the borrower’s downside, but typically at a materially lower LTV than full-recourse on the same underlying. That protection is valuable where the pledged position represents a substantial portion of net worth. For borrowers seeking maximum capital release, full-recourse may be more appropriate; for those seeking maximum protection, non-recourse may be.
Q · 02

Can the recourse profile be changed mid-loan?

Yes, but it is uncommon: the structure is typically set at inception and runs to maturity. Where a borrower’s circumstances change materially, the more common path is to renegotiate the recourse profile or refinance into a new structure. Such changes include a significant event at the underlying issuer or a change in the borrower’s personal balance sheet.
Q · 03

Does the firm have a preferred recourse profile?

No: the firm’s preferred structure is whichever recourse profile is right for the specific borrower and position. The structural discipline is to identify that profile during the indicative-terms stage and to issue terms that match. Where the borrower has not made a choice, the firm typically issues indicative terms across multiple profiles for explicit comparison.
Confidential Enquiries

A specific position to discuss?

Submit a confidential enquiry. A senior principal will respond within one business day.